I help business owners create and execute winning strategic plans that result in growth. Strategic Planning - Coaching - Financial Coaching - Heart for Non-Profits and Ministries.
|
Not every good ministry needs to keep existing. That's a difficult truth for churches to accept, especially when a ministry has a long history, dedicated volunteers, and meaningful stories of lives that have been changed. Most ministries begin because someone sees a need and responds to it. People invest their time, energy, and resources to make something happen. Over the years, traditions develop, relationships form, and the ministry becomes part of the church's identity. But what happens when the need changes? When participation steadily declines? When the resources required to sustain the ministry are no longer justified by its impact? Too often, the answer is nothing. We simply keep doing what we've always done. When history becomes the reasonI've watched churches continue ministries long after their effectiveness had diminished, not because anyone believed they were still accomplishing their original purpose, but because nobody wanted to have the conversation about ending them. The argument usually sounds something like this: "But we've always done it." Or, "Think about all the people who have served in that ministry." Those are understandable sentiments. They're just not sufficient reasons to continue investing limited resources in something that no longer serves the mission. A ministry's history deserves to be honored. It doesn't automatically justify its future. And every dollar, staff hour, and volunteer commitment spent sustaining an ineffective ministry is a resource that can't be invested somewhere else. Have the conversationSuppose your church has operated a particular outreach ministry for twenty years. It once reached hundreds of people, but participation has declined significantly, volunteer leadership is exhausted, and the ministry no longer produces the impact it once did. You know something needs to change, but the people who built the ministry are deeply invested in keeping it alive. Instead of announcing a decision without discussion or avoiding the issue altogether, begin with an honest conversation. You might say: "I want to begin by acknowledging what this ministry has meant to our church. For years, it served people well, and that's worth celebrating. But we also need to look honestly at where we are today. Participation has declined, the demands on our volunteers have increased, and we're not seeing the impact we once did." "I think we need to consider whether continuing this ministry in its current form is the best way to accomplish our mission. That may mean changing it significantly, combining it with something else, or bringing it to a close. I know that's difficult, but I believe we owe it to the ministry and the people who built it to have an honest conversation." Notice that you're not dismissing the past. You're acknowledging it while refusing to let it determine every future decision. Ending well is part of leading wellOf course, declining participation alone doesn't mean a ministry should end. Some ministries serve small populations with extraordinary impact. Others need renewed leadership, a different approach, or more time. The question isn't simply whether a ministry is growing. It's whether it continues to fulfill a meaningful purpose in a responsible and sustainable way. When the answer is no, courageous leadership may require bringing it to an end. That doesn't mean treating the people who served as though their work was wasted. Thank them publicly. Celebrate the stories. Preserve what should be remembered. And when possible, help them discover new ways to contribute. Sometimes the most faithful thing a leader can do is bring a good ministry to a good ending. A question for you: Is there a ministry in your church that everyone knows needs to change, but nobody wants to talk about? Bryan Blackford Free Resource: Should This Ministry Continue.pdf Bryan Blackford |
I help business owners create and execute winning strategic plans that result in growth. Strategic Planning - Coaching - Financial Coaching - Heart for Non-Profits and Ministries.